
Newcastle on the Brink of History—Can Arsenal Stage a Dramatic EFL Cup Comeback?
Newcastle United vs Arsenal Prediction: Newcastle United will likely secure their EFL Cup final spot despite potentially losing 2-1 to Arsenal on the night, advancing with a 3-2 aggregate victory, based on their two-goal first-leg advantage, strong home record of winning three of their last four matches against Arsenal, and the Gunners’ key absences of Jesus, Saka, and Tomiyasu.

| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Competition | EFL Cup Semi-Final Second Leg |
| Date | February 5, 2025 |
| Kickoff | 20:00 GMT |
| Venue | St. James’ Park |
| First Leg Result | Arsenal 0-2 Newcastle |
| Referee | Simon Hooper |
| TV Coverage | See broadcast section below |
Newcastle United welcomes Arsenal to St. James’ Park with a significant advantage in this EFL Cup semi-final tie. The Magpies secured a commanding 2-0 victory at the Emirates through goals from Alexander Isak and Anthony Gordon, putting them in prime position to reach their first League Cup final in 48 years.
Newcastle United Lineup (Expected 4-3-3): Pope; Livramento, Botman, Schar, Hall; Tonali, Guimaraes, Joelinton; Murphy, Isak, Gordon
Arsenal Lineup (Expected 4-3-3): Raya; Timber, Saliba, Gabriel, Lewis-Skelly; Odegaard, Partey, Rice; Martinelli, Havertz, Trossard
Newcastle’s approach under Eddie Howe has proven effective against Arsenal, particularly at St. James’ Park. The Magpies’ high-pressing system and quick transitions have troubled Mikel Arteta’s side in recent meetings. Arsenal’s possession-based style must adapt to break down Newcastle’s resolute defense while maintaining defensive stability.
Recent meetings favor Newcastle, particularly at St. James’ Park:
UK: Sky Sports Main Event, Sky Sports Football
USA: Paramount+
International: Check local listings
Newcastle United’s home record:
Arsenal’s away form:
Newcastle United:
Arsenal:
Given Newcastle’s two-goal advantage and strong home record against Arsenal, combined with key absences for the Gunners, Newcastle appears well-positioned to reach the final despite potentially losing on the night. The tactical battle between Howe and Arteta will prove crucial in determining the outcome.
This semi-final second leg presents a fascinating tactical contest between two sides with contrasting styles and objectives. Arsenal must balance attacking necessity with defensive stability, while Newcastle can afford to be more measured in their approach.
Also Read: Coventry City vs Leeds United Prediction
Sky Sports Main Event and Sky Sports Football will broadcast the Newcastle United vs Arsenal EFL Cup semi-final second leg live in the UK, while Paramount+ streams the match in the USA.
Newcastle United holds the advantage to progress with their 2-0 first-leg lead, though Arsenal might win the individual match 2-1 but fall short on aggregate.
The Newcastle United vs Arsenal EFL Cup semi-final second leg kicks off at 20:00 GMT on February 5, 2025, at St. James’ Park.
Newcastle United misses Harvey Barnes and Jamaal Lascelles while Arsenal is without Gabriel Jesus, Bukayo Saka, and Takehiro Tomiyasu for this crucial cup tie.
Arsenal may secure a 2-1 victory on the night, but Newcastle United advances 3-2 on aggregate to reach their first League Cup final since 1976.